
Mistral Small 4 vs Gemma 4: Open Models Compared for Agents and Local Use
By Nathan Cole
MyClaw Editorial
MyClaw
Run Best-in-Class AI Agents Now
Run OpenClaw or Hermes Agent on managed MyClaw hosting, so your AI agent stays online, updated, and ready for real work.
AI Takeaway
- Which wins overall, Mistral Small 4 or Gemma 4? Pick Gemma 4 31B or 26B A4B for most local and agent work, because Google reports stronger GPQA Diamond results and, by our estimate, a 4-bit copy fits on a single workstation card, and save Small 4 for cheap, quick calls through Mistral's paid API.
- Which Gemma 4 size competes with Mistral Small 4? The closest rivals are the dense 31B and the mixture-of-experts 26B A4B, while Google aims E2B and E4B at phones and edge devices and adds audio input to those two and the 12B Unified.
- Is Gemma 4 free to use commercially? Yes, Google ships every Gemma 4 checkpoint under Apache 2.0, which is also the licence Mistral chose for Small 4.
- How much memory does each need? Google's own table lists roughly 17.5 GB for the 31B at 4-bit and about 14.4 GB for the 26B A4B, whereas Mistral's stated floor for the 119B Small 4 is a multi-GPU server such as four H100 HGX boards.
- Can I run Gemma 4 in a hosted agent? Yes, MyClaw offers Gemma 4 as a model choice for managed agents built with OpenClaw or Hermes Agent, so you can test it on real recurring jobs without buying hardware.
One Mistral Model, Five Gemma Sizes
Mistral released Small 4 on March 16, 2026 (API name mistral-small-2603). It is a single sparse model: 119B parameters overall, about 6.5B used per token, with 4 of 128 experts firing at each step. The window is 256K tokens, it reads text and images, and its reasoning_effort parameter toggles between a fast reply mode (none) and a deliberate one (high).
Google took the opposite route. Its Gemma releases page shows four checkpoints landing on March 31, 2026 (E2B, E4B, 31B and 26B A4B), multi-token prediction draft models following on April 16, and a 12B Unified checkpoint arriving on June 3. Every size carries Apache 2.0 terms, a native system role, function calling, pre-training on more than 140 languages (35+ supported without extra tuning, per Google), and a thinking mode you turn on by placing the <|think|> token at the start of the system prompt.

So the real contest is Small 4 against whichever Gemma size suits your hardware. If you want Gemma placed next to Google's hosted flagship instead, our breakdown of Gemma against Gemini 4 covers that pairing. And if you are deciding inside the Mistral lineup, see how Small 4 stacks up against Mistral Large 3.
Spec Table: Small 4 Against Gemma's 31B and 26B A4B
Sources: Mistral's model docs and Google's Gemma 4 model card, both read on October 14, 2026.
| Spec | Small 4 (Mistral) | Gemma 31B | Gemma 26B A4B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Design | Sparse MoE | Dense | Sparse MoE |
| Parameters | 119B total, ~6.5B active | 30.7B | 25.2B total, 3.8B active |
| Experts | 4 of 128, plus 1 shared | None | 8 of 128, plus 1 shared |
| Layers | 36 | 60 | 30 |
| Context | 256K | 256K | 256K |
| Input | Text + vision | Text + vision | Text + vision |
| Reasoning switch | reasoning_effort none/high | Thinking token | Thinking token |
| Licence | Apache 2.0 | Same | Same |
| Release | Mar 16, 2026 | Mar 31, 2026 | Mar 31, 2026 |
The smaller Gemma checkpoints fill gaps that Small 4 leaves open. E2B (2.3B effective) and E4B (4.5B effective) carry a 128K window and accept audio, as does the 12B Unified with its 256K window. Small 4 takes no audio, so voice work points to Gemma.
Note the active-parameter gap too. Per token, Small 4 activates more weights (~6.5B) than the 26B A4B (3.8B), yet far fewer than the dense 31B, which uses all 30.7B on every step.

Benchmarks: What the Vendors Publish
Only one test appears in both vendors' published results: GPQA Diamond, a graduate-level science quiz.
| Benchmark | Small 4 | Gemma 31B | Gemma 26B A4B |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPQA Diamond | 71.2 (Mistral) | 84.3 (Google) | 82.3 (Google) |
| MMLU Pro | — | 85.2 | 82.6 |
| LiveCodeBench v6 | See note | 80.0 | 77.1 |
| AIME 2026 | — | 89.2 | 88.3 |
| Tau2 (agent tool use) | — | 76.9 | 68.2 |
| MMMU Pro (vision) | — | 76.9 | 73.8 |
On coding, Mistral gives no LiveCodeBench score for Small 4. It says only that the model matches or beats GPT-OSS 120B there while writing roughly 20% less output, so we leave that cell qualitative.
Treat the shared row with care. Each company ran its own evaluation with its own prompts, sampling settings and harness, and neither has published the other's model under identical conditions. A 13-point GPQA gap is large enough to suggest a real difference, but it is not a controlled head-to-head.
Independent data narrows the picture a little. Artificial Analysis, a third-party benchmarking site, gave Gemma 4 31B an Intelligence Index of 15 and Small 4 an 11 when we checked on October 14. It also lists a 17 for the 26B A4B, but marks that figure as estimated, so we do not lean on it. The same site measured output speed at about 35 tokens per second for the 31B, around 69 for the 26B A4B and roughly 165 for Small 4 on the endpoints it tracks, a figure shaped by provider hardware. For another open-weight pairing judged on these lines, read our Gemma and Qwen 3.6 comparison.
![]()
Cost: API Tokens vs Your Own GPU
Small 4 costs $0.15 per 1M input tokens, with output billed at $0.60 per 1M, on Mistral's API (Mistral pricing, October 14, 2026). Batch jobs get 50% off, and cached input can be discounted by up to 90%.
Google's Gemini API pricing page lists Gemma 4 as free of charge on the free tier, with the paid tier marked "Not available". The page names Gemma 4 as one entry and does not spell out which checkpoints sit behind it, so check the model list in your own account. Free-tier traffic comes with rate limits, and Google says it can use such prompts for product improvement, which rules it out for many company workloads.
Self-hosting is where the size gap really shows. Google's memory table for loading weights reads:
| Checkpoint | 16-bit | 8-bit | 4-bit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gemma 31B | 69.9 GB | 34.9 GB | 17.5 GB |
| Gemma 26B A4B | 57.7 GB | 28.8 GB | 14.4 GB |
| Gemma E4B | — | — | 4.5 GB |
These cover weights only; long contexts add KV-cache memory. Our estimate from those figures: a 24 GB consumer card can hold either mid-size Gemma at 4-bit. Mistral lists the minimum for Small 4 as four H100 HGX boards, two H200 HGX boards or a single DGX B200; that rules out local use for most solo developers. The write-up pitting Small 4 against Qwen 3.6 walks through the same hardware question against another rival.
Which Model Fits Your Setup
| Situation | Better pick |
|---|---|
| Phone or edge device | Gemma 4 E2B or E4B |
| One workstation GPU, speed first | Gemma 4 26B A4B |
| One workstation GPU, quality first | Gemma 4 31B |
| Audio input | Gemma 4 E4B or 12B Unified |
| High-volume paid API calls | Small 4 via Mistral |
| Existing Mistral stack and tooling | Mistral Small 4 |
| Managed agent, no servers | Gemma 4 on MyClaw |
Mistral Small 4
- Pros: very low published token price; fast measured output; one checkpoint for chat, code, vision and reasoning; batch and cache discounts.
- Cons: needs data-centre hardware to self-host; no audio; few published benchmark numbers.
Gemma 4 31B
- Pros: top scores in Google's table; leads the 26B A4B on every benchmark Google lists; fits a 24 GB card at 4-bit by our estimate.
- Cons: slowest of the three in third-party speed tests; every parameter runs on each token.
Gemma 4 26B A4B
- Pros: only 3.8B active weights, so it decodes quickly; smallest memory footprint of the mid-size options; scores close to the 31B on most rows.
- Cons: clearly weaker than the 31B on Tau2 tool use (68.2 vs 76.9); all 25.2B weights must still sit in memory even though only 3.8B run per token.

Verdict: Gemma 4 for Most Builders, Small 4 for API Volume
For anyone who wants to own the weights, Gemma 4 wins on almost every axis that matters day to day. It posts higher vendor scores, runs on one card, and comes in sizes from phone to workstation, all under Apache 2.0. The 31B is the steadier option for agents that call tools, given its Tau2 lead, while the 26B A4B suits chat front ends where response speed counts.
Small 4 earns its place when you would rather pay per token than run anything. With its low list rates plus steep batch and cache discounts, it is hard to undercut for bulk classification, extraction or support routing, and Mistral's endpoint is quick.
For agents, our OpenClaw model rankings sort more candidates by how reliably they call tools.
Put Gemma 4 to Work in a MyClaw Agent
MyClaw runs the agent stack on its own servers and lists Gemma 4 among its models, so a trial takes minutes:
- Sign up on MyClaw and launch a hosted agent, choosing OpenClaw or Hermes.
- Set Gemma 4 as the model this agent runs on.
- Connect your chat app. Give the agent one recurring task to start.
New to the framework? Our OpenClaw explainer covers how its agents handle scheduled work.
Skip the Setup, Run Best-in-Class AI Agents Now
Launch a managed OpenClaw or Hermes Agent workspace in minutes, with always-on hosting, updates, and support handled by MyClaw.